Wednesday, July 11, 2007

San Francisco Next Plans to Solve the Ladder Falls Problem by Repealing Law of Gravity

I keep remembering what it was like living in the Bay Area--a place where much of the population believes that they have a constitutional right to pretend that there is no objective reality. That's the only explanation for San Francisco's continuing attempts to avoid facing what is really causing their violence problem:
The bulk of a package of gun control legislation intended to help stem the gun violence plaguing San Francisco advanced Monday -- though even the legislation's co-sponsors aren't sure how much good it will do.

The Public Safety Committee of the Board of Supervisors sent three of the four pieces of legislation -- introduced by Mayor Gavin Newsom in May -- to the full board.

Under those three measures, residents would have to keep handguns in locked containers or disable the guns with trigger locks. The mayor's administration said this would help prevent children from playing with guns and guns from being stolen from homes and used in crimes.
How many gun deaths does San Francisco have caused by children "playing" with guns they found around the house? If there's even one a year I would be very, very surprised.

The second reason makes a bit more sense. But how long does it take to remove a gun lock from a firearm once you have carried it out of the home? They use a key and cylinder to hold the lock in place. That takes a drill and perhaps five minutes of work.

Locked containers that are chained or bolted down to a stud or fixture probably do make a difference in preventing theft of guns (especially handguns). If they passed a law requiring that, I might be irritated by it, but it at least has the potential to reduce thefts, especially by criminals who are in a hurry to get in and out. But the gun lock requirement is just playing to the idiots who dominate San Francisco politics, and know nothing about the subject.

Also under the legislation, licensed firearms dealers would have to provide an inventory of their firearms to the police chief every six months. They would need to provide a listing of each firearm in their inventory as well as the makes, models and serial numbers. They would also need to provide a list of every firearm sold, lost or stolen in those six months.

"It's an opportunity to strengthen our information about what guns are being sold, what guns aren't being accounted for, if any," said Lenore Anderson, director of the mayor's criminal justice office.
There's no question in my mind that there are some licensed dealers who are careless, and I have read of one case where two guys got a dealer's license specifically to go into business to sell guns to criminals--no paperwork, not even an attempt at pretending. They transferred over 800 guns in a few months on the streets of South Central, each incident being a federal felony--and received nine months and twelve months, respectively, in federal prison for it.

But the notion that the only licensed gun dealer in San Francisco is a source of stolen or lost guns is absurd. Someone's just trying to drive the one legal dealer out.

The fourth piece of legislation -- the creation of a local registry of gun offenders convicted in San Francisco -- was held, pending further work by the Newsom administration to ensure it doesn't encroach on civil liberties.

The mayor has proposed creating a Police Department registry of convicted gun offenders. The offenders would need to register every six months for four years after conviction and alert the department of any changes of address within 10 days of moving.

Supervisor Ross Mirkarimi, head of the committee and a sponsor of the legislation along with Supervisor Sophie Maxwell, said he thought the registry of gun offenders proposal would still make it to the full board. But he said he wasn't convinced the gun control package as a whole would have much effect on gun violence.

"I would like to believe so, but I don't think we're getting to the heart of why San Francisco is experiencing this unabated gun violence citywide," he said.
This is so profoundly bizarre to me. What constitutes "a convicted gun offender"? Armed robbers? Murderers? Rather than making them register--why aren't they in prison?

And Supervisor Mirkarimi at least recognizes that this isn't going to work. I can't believe that anyone on the Board of Supervisors really believes that this is going to make a difference--unless they are truly too stupid to buy bread at the market without assistance. But what is reality when you live in San Francisco? Just part of the right-wing conspiracy.

He said many guns are coming illegally into San Francisco from dealers outside its limits, which the city can do little about. In addition, he said, criminals come into the city with guns to commit illegal activity without fear of being arrested or prosecuted.
How are the guns "coming illegally" into San Francisco? Does he mean that San Francisco residents may not lawfully buy guns elsewhere? Or does he mean that criminals are obtaining their guns from dealers outside San Francisco? In addition to the federal background check for all guns, California has a more exhaustive background check system, with a mandatory ten day waiting period, for all gun transfers. This isn't a problem of "dealers outside its limits" but of a gun control law that amazingly enough, doesn't seem to work very well.

He is right about this: "criminal come into the city with guns to commit illegal activity without fear of being arrested or prosecuted." And they will be even less afraid when San Francisco city emplyees are busily maintaining a "gun offenders registry" and pouring over the records from the only licensed gun store every six months.

Tuesday, July 10, 2007

More About Salisbury's Campaign For Bill Sali's Seat

Over at Idaho Chooses Life (a site I don't think I have ever visited before), they discuss Mr. Salisbury's position:
But this does not exactly settle the matter. I am mystified that Mr. Salisbury has chosen to anchor his campaign message in the philosophy of Planned Parenthood – you know, the rhetoric which claims that “the government has no business in our bedrooms”. Apparently it has something to do with his belief that Christians in public life ought not be very explicit about imposing our faith upon others. As the campaign develops he will have opportunity to better express his ideas.

We also know nothing about Mr. Salisbury's position on specific policy questions. That may be where we will find the conflict. But on the phone, he was adamant that he found abortion "abhorrent".

In any event, the biggest question that nags is why Mr. Salisbury is running at all. The media’s original description of his candidacy explained he was unhappy with Congressman Sali’s pro-Life politics. After our phone conversation yesterday, it seems that is not the issue. So now I’m left wondering why a pro-Life person would squander resources and enhance Democrat chances for taking the seat by challenging an incumbent with an unmatched pro-Life record.

It is very curious, and perhaps we will learn more about motivations as Mr. Salisbury refines his message in coming months.
Me too.

I don't think that a general ban on abortion makes a great deal of sense, because there is a large minority of Americans that support utterly unrestricted abortion--and some of them are prepared to go to prison to make sure that abortion remains available. You could pass a general ban on abortion--but you would need a heck of a lot of prison space to lock up all the criminals. The most that such a law would do is reduce advertising of such services, perhaps reducing the abortion rate somewhat, but like Prohibition, making it illegal would aggravate other problems. (Example: A D&X abortion often causes substantial and sometimes deadly infections; I'm sure that someone who was suffering a severe infection after an illegal abortion would delay going to a doctor or an emergency room for fear that it would come to light.)

If you want to make a real difference in the abortion rate, you need to tackle the underlying social problems that are causing so many women and men to be irresponsible about sex and contraception. Change that part of the social equation, and it will be both easier to get abortion restricted, and it will reduce the destructive side effects of prohibiting abortion when the time comes to change the law.

If Mr. Salisbury is as pro-life as the account above indicates, then trying to defeat Bill Sali on the abortion issue makes absolutely no sense. If the objective is to replace Bill Sali because he has become a lightning rod of liberal hostility, that might make some sense--but Sali's social conservatism, as near as I can tell, is the primary reason that Idaho liberals find Sali detestable. I'm sure if Bill Sali were supporting gay marriage, abortion on demand, and higher taxes, his style would be called "challenging, idealistic, and no-nonsense."
Ron Paul for President Signs

I'm seeing them around Boise now. Not many--which means that there is probably one Ron Paul supporter here. If there were five Ron Paul supporters here, it would be hard to find your way down the streets because of the number of signs.

I voted for Ron Paul for President when he was the Libertarian Party candidate some years ago. I don't think I would do it now. Even at the time, if I thought he had a realistic chance, I might have not voted for him. I can remember reading one letter from him that came perilously close to "the Jews run everything" in its discussion of U.S. foreign policy--and back then, as now, I have a certain skepticism of Israel that I know is not widely shared among other evangelical Christians.
Religious Adherents Map

Bryan Fischer at Idaho Values Alliance brought this map to my attention. It shows what percentage of the population by county identifies with 149 religious bodies that participated in a 2000 survey.



Click to get it larger.

There are some unsurprising parts of the map. Utah and eastern Idaho (with its large Mormon population) has very high percentages. The Midwest and some parts of the South are also pretty thick. The West Coast (except for a few remarkable counties in California and eastern Washington) is not terribly strong.

A lot of states that have reputations for being politically quite conservative (Virginia, most of Idaho, Florida, Maine) are not, by this map, terribly religious--at least with respect to traditional organized religion. Remember that religion and conservative politics don't have a perfect correlation. Much of Los Angeles County's high adherents rate is probably centered in South Central Los Angeles, and Massachusetts and much of Connecticut have very high rates of religious adherents, but aren't even slightly conservative.

Another point to remember is that a lot of what calls itself "conservative" in politics is really more libertarian. In many cases, those who call themselves conservative don't really understand the difference, and in other cases, prefer to call themselves "conservative" because it doesn't have the negative baggage that the Libertarian Party has unintentionally attached to that term. A lot of libertarian Republicans are not ideological purists; they don't think the government should be going around actively pursuing pot smokers, but they also wouldn't buy into repealing laws against cocaine or heroin.

Here in Idaho, there is an uneasy alliance between social conservatives, libertarians, and non-ideological Big Business Republicans. I can disagree with libertarian Republicans on some policies, and yet see some merit to their concerns. In many cases, applying a libertarian approach with moderation can be useful. For example, I suspect that if prostitution were made legal--and tightly regulated, as is done in some Nevada counties--it would probably be a net gain for the society (although not for a fair number of individuals).

My impression is that the libertarian and conservative Republicans have managed to make a bit of common cause over the years, but the Big Business Republicans have been howling as they have lost influence (and I mean that in the perjorative sense of the word). A former neighbor of mine was a member of the Idaho State Senate for several terms, but eventually decided to stop running because corporate contributions diminished so dramatically that he couldn't justify spending that much of his own money to win re-election. He was voting his conscience and the interests of his constituents--and that was often not that of business interests here.
All The Things That Global Warming Causes

This site has a complete list of links to articles blaming all sorts of stuff on global warming. Oh my! Especially for the last line!

I'm reminded of a Shoe cartoon strip from the 1980s, in which the editor has a thought bubble above his head, "Earthquakes, famines, hurricanes... It's all Reagan's fault."
Running for Congress Isn't Cheap

I was looking over the campaign finance reports for the Idaho 1st Congressional seat from 2006. The winner, Bill Sali, spent more than a million dollars--and $10,000 was his own money. The Democrat who lost, Larry Grant, spent more than $700,000 (of which more than $80,000 came out of his own pocket).

Even the losers in the Republican primary for that race spent big money. Sheila Sorensen, for example, spent more than $400,000--and $218,152 were from her own pocket.

A member of the House earns $165,200 per year--so even if Sorensen had won the election, she would barely have earned that money back before the next election cycle starts up, and you have to start spending money again.
BBC (Of All Organizations) Reports That The Surge May Be Working


Yes, I'm shocked as well:
He said everyone wanted the US forces to be able to leave, both Americans and Iraqis alike, but he said it was vital to ensure that "the gains that have been hard fought in places like Baquba and Ramadi could be sustained, maintained and even built on by Iraqi forces and Iraqi political leaders".

The violence has subsided in Ramadi over the past six months - largely, correspondents say, because tribes have turned against al-Qaeda. The Americans have taken parts of Baquba, but it is still unclear how much they control.