Monday, July 9, 2007

Idaho Politics

There's a Republican challenging Bill Sali for Congress next year--and it has already generated a storm of upset.

NAMPA -- An Iraq War veteran plans to run for Idaho's 1st District Congress seat as a Republican, meaning U.S. Representative Bill Sali likely will face a rival in the May 2008 primary.

Matt Salisbury, a 34-year-old Nampa resident, described himself as a "Lincoln Republican" who believes politicians should stay "out of your bedroom and out of your social mores."
Idaho Chooses Life, which is an Idaho pro-life group, wasn't too happy about this:
A press release reported by Boise’s KTVB late last week says that Nampa resident Matt Salisbury will challenge Congressman Bill Sali in next year’s GOP Primary.

We don’t know this gentlemen, but the press release describes him as a decorated veteran of the Airborne Rangers. He has also seen active duty in Iraq with the National Guard. Before saying anything else about his campaign – let us give thanks for his bravery and service to nation.

Mr. Salisbury’s honorable battlefield experience does not, however, qualify him as a candidate for Congress.

It is obvious from his opening statement that he is committed to defending abortion rights in this country. This is perhaps his primary reason for running. He goes so far as to say that “government should stay out of our bedrooms”. That suggests he may also be a defender of gay rights and other social aberrations – but we’ll have to see what else he has to say.

We are most troubled, however, by his claim to be a “Lincoln Republican”. Someone must rise to defend the late President’s honor from modern social radicals who would cloak their agendas in his legitimizing mantle. (The gay rights crowd has long maligned Abraham Lincoln’s memory by organizing themselves as the “Log Cabin Republicans” – for reasons totally beyond a coherent retelling here).

There is absolutely nothing in the public record to support the notion that President Lincoln, were he alive today, would be a champion of abortion rights. If anything, his articulation of the proper and moral role of government qualify him for title as “First Pro-Life President of the Republic”.

Many of us in the Pro-Life Movement read his speeches and courageous indictment of slavery as succor in our struggle against the destruction of God’s Little Ones. In the face of great opposition, Lincoln eventually molded the Civil War into a great moral struggle against evil; he led a bloody defense of the dignity of each human being.

Mr. Salisbury is entitled to his views on abortion – which views disqualify him for public office. But we hope that he quickly ends his campaign to malign the memory of Mr. Lincoln.
Okay, it didn't take long before I saw an upset email from Mr. Salisbury's wife concerned about Bill Sali misrepresenting her husband. I won't reproduce the letter (since I don't know whether it was intended for publication), but my first reaction was that if Mr. Salisbury is pro-life, using an expression like that was a rather odd way of saying so. I asked for clarification from Mrs. Salisbury--and the response that I received left me unable to figure out what Mr. Salisbury's position is on abortion--but it does not appear to be supportive of any sort of a ban.

I also haven't been able to get a clear answer if the "government out of the bedroom" remark means that Mr. Salisbury opposes sodomy laws as a matter of public policy (a legitimate position, I think) or as a matter of Constitutional right (clearly historically wrong). I can't tell if I am seeing muddled thinking, muddled writing, or an attempt at straddling the pro-life and pro-choice camps. (This is rather like trying to straddle a bull and a whale simultaneously--it takes remarkable legs).

UPDATE: Idaho Values Alliance directory Bryan Fischer reports that Salisbury says he is being misquoted:
He insisted in an email to me yesterday that his quote was taken out of context, and accused the press of essentially twisting his words in its quest for a story. In a preliminary conservation Mr. Salisbury and I had this morning, he indicated that his remarks regarding "social mores" and "social engineering" were actually directed toward liberals who seek to use the law to impose their politically correct views of such things as the homosexual lifestyle, child-raising and education on the rest of society.
If so, this is a good sign for Mr. Salisbury. But it is a reminder of the importance of good press release writing.

Many years ago, I was active in Libertarian Party politics in Southern California. (I was younger, more idealistic, and less aware of history.) One of our candidates for state legislature had the mildly embarrassing situation of being arrested and convicted of drug dealing in the middle of the election campaign. He served his sentence--and went on to get the highest vote percentage of any LP candidate that year. (Admittedly, it was one of the few races where the LP candidate only had one major party opponent.)

I had a chance to see the press release that this candidate sent out about something that would ordinarily be considered a campaign faux pas--spending time in federal prison during the campaign. It went on for many pages--and the newspapers, being generally hostile to libertarian ideas, picked the worst parts of it for their news story (since the journalists couldn't be bothered with actually going out and interviewing anyone), and left out the parts that presented him in a positive light. (He was apparently selected for a "one step from entrapment" prosecution because he refused to provide Qualludes to a neighbor, who was planning to use them to get a 15 year old girl in the mood for sex. The neighbor was a federal informant.)

I still look forward to hearing from Mr. Salisbury about his positions.
Journalists Go Gun Shopping

It is always somewhat interesting to watch what happens when a journalist decides to explore the dark and evil subculture of gun ownership. Sometimes, they actually seem to be trying to be fair and honest! Anyway, you might find this series of articles from the Lawrence, Kansas Journal interesting. The first one is titled, "Buying into the Gun Culture," where the reporter tells us of going out to buy a handgun for concealed carry, since he is going to be going through the process of buying a handgun, getting a carry permit, carrying a gun for a few days, and seeing how it goes. From his description, it sounds like the various gun dealers he talked to (and who didn't know he was a reporter) were upfront and sensible people--which is what I would expect.

This other article from July 1, 2007 interviews a local person who was an opponent of the new Kansas concealed carry law--and unlike a lot of these reports, it really captures a lot of why this gal is so hostile to gun ownership:
When Marilyn Roy talks about parts of her past, she clutches her purse tightly. She rocks with it in her chair as she talks about the times that turned violent. Her life in Barstow, although isolated — or acultural, as she describes it — wasn’t necessarily serene.

“I grew up in a troubled family,” Roy said. “My family wasn’t hunky-dory.”

Roy, 57, found hard times on her own, too. She was forced to put her son up for adoption when he was 5, for reasons she did not disclose. Afterward, she went to Kansas City to try to start over, but instead she found a dead end. She was homeless in Kansas City and Texas for about four years.

On the streets, she saw the drugs, she saw the guns, she saw the violence. Some of it found her, too. Roy said she’s been the victim of domestic violence and physical abuse on multiple occasions.

The violence left her with a choice to make. She said a person can either choose to fight violence with violence, or take the tack that violence begets nothing good.

“The consequence of violence being fought with violence just doesn’t appeal to me,” Roy said.

Since 1974, Roy has been spreading that message in Lawrence. That’s how long she has lived in the city, spending part of the time as a student. She has a degree in psychology and runs a small home-based business called Simplify, a home/office organization business that has a motto of “supporting peaceful lifestyles.” She’s also on a Social Security disability related to some of the emotional scars from her past. She’s likely best known to many Lawrence residents as a frequent advocate at City Hall and elsewhere for people who are disadvantaged.

“I’ve come to the conclusion that I was just born a pacifist,” Roy said.
I feel bad for Ms. Roy, but it is a reminder that a lot of the more extreme anti-gun sorts are engaged in projection. They confuse themselves with the average person.

There's also a very fair article about one of the gun rights activists in Lawrence.
Remember When People Made Fun of Vice President Quayle's Remarks About Mars?

He said something about the potential for living on Mars that I suspect was what he remembered from a science class in the 1950s--when we didn't really know very much yet about Mars and its potential for human habitation.

So why isn't anyone making fun of this other, former Vice President's ignorance? From the July 1, 2007 New York Times:
We — all of us — now face a universal threat. Though it is not from outside this world, it is nevertheless cosmic in scale.

Consider this tale of two planets. Earth and Venus are almost exactly the same size, and have almost exactly the same amount of carbon. The difference is that most of the carbon on Earth is in the ground — having been deposited there by various forms of life over the last 600 million years — and most of the carbon on Venus is in the atmosphere.

As a result, while the average temperature on Earth is a pleasant 59 degrees, the average temperature on Venus is 867 degrees. True, Venus is closer to the Sun than we are, but the fault is not in our star; Venus is three times hotter on average than Mercury, which is right next to the Sun. It’s the carbon dioxide.
Parts of this statement are simply false. Mercury's sunlit side is 872 degrees Fahrenheit.

The statement about Venus's atmosphere is true, but misleading; Venus is remarkably hot because of the amount of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. But guess what? All planets start out with a methane, ammonia, water vapor atmosphere, and evolve to a carbon dioxide, nitrogen, water vapor atmosphere. Mars has a comparably carbon dioxide rich atmosphere--and yet it isn't terribly warm. Why?

There are two major differences between the Earth and Venus that makes this comparison absurd.

1. Venus is 72% of the distance from the Sun as the Earth. That means that it gets 1.93 times the solar input. That's a big difference. Even if we had comparable atmospheres, Venus would be a lot warmer.

2. The presence of large bodies of liquid water on the early Earth--because we were getting about half the sunlight--provided both a basis for life--which converts quite a bit of atmospheric and oceanic carbon dioxide into glucose--and a geochemical process for converting carbon dioxide into carbonates. There is about 40x as much carbon dioxide locked up in carbonate minerals as there is in the atmosphere. The mechanisms are not spectacularly well understood.

This is just scaremongering by Al Gore--a person who clearly doesn't know much about the chemistry behind planetary atmospheres.

Sunday, July 8, 2007

Ratatouille

My wife and I went to see this early this afternoon with our daughter and son-in-law, and we can wholeheartedly endorse this as a fine family film. It was funny, it was cleverly written, very well done computer graphics mixed with (I think) occasional actual film. There was no double entendre, no off-color references, no profanities, a few mild surprises along the way. Unlike Shrek 2, which profoundly disappointed me with its transgenderism and unnecessarily raw language, Ratatouille was a gem of a family film--a reminder that a G-rated film can be something that adults can enjoy as much as the kids.

If you want to see more movies like this made: vote with your dollars. Run right and see it.

UPDATE: A reader tells me that in the credits is a statement that they used no motion capture techniques--which would suggest that they didn't use any real photography, either. If so--even more impressive technically!

Saturday, July 7, 2007

Thomas Szasz

I've always wondered how Thomas Szasz, who had been trained as a psychiatrist, could hold to his outlandish claims that psychoses such as schizophrenia do not exist. Would not the exposure to psychotic patients during training have shown Szasz the error of his ideology? It turns out that Szasz may not have had much exposure to psychotics. In a 1997 interview, he describes how he consciously selected a psychiatric residency “that did not include work with involuntary patients.” The chairman of the Psychiatry Department told him, “Tom, you have only one year left of your residency. I don’t think it’s right that you should finish without any experience with psychotic patients. I think you should do your third year at the Cook County Hospital.” So Szasz quit, and went elsewhere to avoid getting any experience with psychotic patients.

Szasz was drafted into the Navy after completing his training, and his experiences there almost certainly reinforced his already well developed belief that mental illness did not exist. “The servicemen didn’t want to be in the Navy and played the role of mental patient. I didn’t want to be in the Navy and played the role of military psychiatrist: My job was to discharge the men from the Service as ‘neuropsychiatric casualties’.”

Szasz had gone out of his way to avoid seeing psychotic patients, and then took a job that he describes as certifying that sane people pretending to insane were actually insane. There's something worse than being ignorant--and that's going out of your way to stay ignorant.
Michael Foucault

Torrey and Miller's The Invisible Plague, as you might expect, has some unkind words for R.D. Laing (who argued that insanity was simply a sane response to an insane capitalist world), Thomas Szasz (who denies that schizophrenia is anything but "inappropriate use of metaphors" by the patient), and Michael Foucault.

If you have read a scholarly journal article or book published in the last thirty years, and found yourself wondering, "Am I stupid? Or is this incomprehensible gibberish?" then the odds are good that you have read something either written by Michael Foucault, or by someone who has read too much of Foucault.

Foucault's Madness and Civilization published in English 1965, made the claim that insanity isn't an illness, but an alternative lifestyle, and that mental hospitals were created as a mechanism for oppressing people who were living in that alternative lifestyle. You won't be terribly surprised to hear that Foucault died of AIDS in 1984. From Torrey and Miller, pp. 302-3:
According to his biographers, Foucault was emotionally unstable, made multiple suicide attempts, and, in the view of one friend, "all his life.... verged on madness."

Foucault dressed insanity in hits best philosophical finery: "The symbol of madness will henceforth be that mirror which, without reflecting anything real, will secretly offer the man who observes himself in it the dream of his own presumption. Madness deals not so much with truth and the world, as with man and whatever the truth about himself he is able to perceive." Foucault thus had great appeal to a generation that often mistook obscurantism for wisdom.
"Silent Snow, Secret Snow"

Do you remember reading this in junior high or high school? I think it may have been assigned reading. It is a powerful, highly evocative, pretty scary short story about a young boy's descent into catatonic schizophrenia.

I'm reading E. Fuller Torrey and Judy Miller's The Invisible Plague: The Rise of Mental Illness from 1750 to the Present (New Brunswick, N.J.: Rutgers University Press, 2001), at the moment. The book presents a lot of what at first glance seems pretty persuasive statistical evidence that there was a quite dramatic rise in psychosis in England & Wales, Ireland, Canada's Atlantic provinces, and the United States from the 17th through the 20th centuries. There is pretty reliable statistical information from mental hospital admissions and government censuses from the start of the 19th century, and Torrey and Fuller make use of detailed records of doctors and hospitals from the beginning of the seventeenth century to corroborate other data from the 17th and 18th centuries that isn't quite as comprehensive.

What makes this so interesting is that Torrey is a big proponent of the biochemical/genetic origin of schizophrenia. All that I have read leads me to agree. Yet he admits that this dramatic rise in the rates raises interesting questions. I've previously mentioned that some studies show a strong correlation between growing up in an urban area, and developing schizophrenia. The Invisible Plague mentions a variety of studies that show the same, and psychiatrists were noticing the strong correlations between urbanization and psychosis as early as the 1920s. If urbanization explains the rise in psychosis over the last few centuries, then it would suggest that genetics could only be one factor--perhaps a predisposing factor. There would have to be some other specifically urban factor that actuates mental illness.

Anyway, back to "Silent Snow, Secret Snow." The author of that haunting story was Conrad Aiken. The Invisible Plague, p. 294 explains why Aiken was interested in the subject of insanity.
His father, a successful surgeon, killed his wife and then himself because of a delusional belief that his wife was going to have him committed to an insane asylum. Aiken, then age eleven, found their bodies. His younger sister became insane in her early twenties and spent much of her life hospitalized. Aiken himself had periods of depression and made at least one serious suicide attempt. He lived his life fearing that he, too, would become insane and in 1932 wrote "Silent Snow, Secret Snow," which he acknowledged was "a projection of my own inclination to insanity."
UPDATE: Torrey and Miller's book has a discussion at 298-299 that does a nice job of summarizing the evidence for a dramatic increase in mental illness in the United States over a century. They point to the 1880 census of insane persons, and something called the Epidemilogic Catchment Area study "carried out from 1980 to 1985 in New Haven, Baltimore, Durham, St. Louis, and Los Angeles." The ECA study found that 2.2 per cent of adults were diagnosed with schizophrenia and bipolar disorder.

The 1880 census of the insane attempted to identify all mentally ill people--not just those in mental hospitals and workhouses (where a lot of the less dangerous mentally ill were kept in many states). The methodologies aren't quite equivalent, as Torrey and Miller point out.
The 1980s study included some individuals who would not have been counted as insane in 1880 (bipolar disorder II, depression with hypomania), and the 1880 study counted some individuals as insane who would not have been included in the ECA study (e.g., epilepsy with insanity).
Yet the 1880 census of the insane found 0.18 per cent of the total population was insane. Presumably after adjusting for the diagnostic category differences, Torrey and Miller assert that the ECA data shows almost a ninefold increase in insanity.

They also point to the data on those receiving SSI or SSDI payments for "mental disorders other than mental retardation." In 1997, that was 2.5 million people--or 0.94 per cent of the population--more than five times the results of the 1880 census of the insane. It is true that there are people collecting SSI and SSDI who are not insane or even disabled (I've known a few over the years), but I would expect that this is probably roughly balanced by the number of Americans who are so severely mentally ill that they aren't collecting SSI or SSDI.