Sunday, February 3, 2008

Barack Obama, Liar

He was here in Boise over the weekend for a rally, and emphasized that he is not trying to take anyone's guns. He's a liar. It isn't just that he supports bans on semiautomatics, and more possession and purchase restrictions. He claims that he wants more laws to keep guns out of the inner cities. Why? Does he think black people lack the sense that white people have?

He was a member of the board of the Joyce Foundation, the primary funder of extreme gun control measures in the United States. And he claims that he isn't trying to disarm Americans?

He's a liar, through and through.

UPDATE: Welcome, Instapundit readers. Check back here regularly--you will find a lot of material about gun rights issues.

UPDATE 2: Sportsmen for Obama has a number of surprisingly recent statements by Obama that show where he stands on gun control. If you want to have a hunting weapon, that's okay, but for self-defense--or if you live in an "inner city" (which is a euphemism for "black people can't be trusted with guns")--well, you are out of luck.

Interesting Notions of Causes of Mental Illness

In the early 19th century, the causes of mental illness were subject to quite interesting speculations. I've mentioned previously a 1645 diary entry by Governor Winthrop of Massachusetts, who ascribed the insanity of the wife of the governor of Hartford (not yet merged into Connecticut colony) to excessive study and writing books. (Women weren't supposed to write books.)

In looking at T. Romeyn Beck, “Statistical Notices of Some of the Lunatic Asylums of the United States,” Transactions of the Albany Institute (Albany, N.Y.: Webster & Skinners, 1830), I see a list of causes of mental illness from the Connecticut mental hospital opened at Hartford, Connecticut, in 1824. Some of them aren't particularly bizarre ideas for possible causes such as "blow on the head" and others are even today recognized as possible causes of mental illness: "intemperance." But I see eight patients listed as ill because of "excessive study" and six listed as "Predisposition from various causes, (one from novel reading)."

"Honest, professor, I can't study hard enough to get an A on this test--I don't walk to end up hospitalized."

Welfare Benefits for Polygamous Marriages

Good news--this is only in Britain--not the U.S. (so far). From the February 3, 2008 Telegraph, thanks to JammieWearingFool:
Husbands with multiple wives have been given the go-ahead to claim extra welfare benefits following a year-long Government review, The Sunday Telegraph can reveal.

Even though bigamy is a crime in Britain, the decision by ministers means that polygamous marriages can now be recognised formally by the state, so long as the weddings took place in countries where the arrangement is legal.

The outcome will chiefly benefit Muslim men with more than one wife, as is permitted under Islamic law. Ministers estimate that up to a thousand polygamous partnerships exist in Britain, although they admit there is no exact record.
The decision has been condemned by the Tories, who accused the Government of offering preferential treatment to a particular group, and of setting a precedent that would lead to demands for further changes in British law.
New guidelines on income support from the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) state: "Where there is a valid polygamous marriage the claimant and one spouse will be paid the couple rate ... The amount payable for each additional spouse is presently £33.65."
Income support for all of the wives may be paid directly into the husband's bank account, if the family so choose. Under the deal agreed by ministers, a husband with multiple wives may also be eligible for additional housing benefit and council tax benefit to reflect the larger property needed for his family.
The ruling could cost taxpayers millions of pounds. Ministers launched a review of the benefit rules for polygamous marriages in November 2006, after it emerged that some families had benefited financially.
The review concluded in December last year with agreement that the extra benefits should continue to be paid, the Government admitted. The decision was not publicly announced.
Four departments - the Treasury, the DWP, HM Revenue and Customs, and the Home Office - were involved in the review, which concluded that recognising multiple marriages conducted overseas was "the best possible" option. In Britain, bigamy is punishable by up to seven years in prison.
Islamic law permits men to have up to four wives at any one time - known as a harem - provided the husband spends equal amounts of time and money on each of them.
As I have previously mentioned, the ACLU's president several years ago indicated that the ACLU would defend polygamy. I really don't see how the courts will say no once the ACLU files suit to demand legal recognition of polygamy. After all, other countries are doing it--and for the U.S. Supreme Court, that's certainly more important than our Constitution.

We Can't Serve You, Sir--You Are Too Fat

I mentioned a couple of days ago about how the British National Health Service is discussing paying a truly shocking amount of money for "surrogate mothers" to bear children for couples who can't have them (both heterosexual and homosexual couples)--while life threatening illnesses (not elective procedures like this) are too expensive for NHS to handle.

I've also mentioned in the past
that while some legitimate medical procedures were on long waiting lists in Canada, the Ontario Health Minister was enthusiastically supporting having the government pay for sex change operations--a procedure that is at best elective, and at worst, a waste of money.

Now, a friend points me to this proposal being considered in the Mississippi legislature that is a logical outgrowth of the idea that we are all in this together with respect to health insurance--a law that would prohibit restaurants from serving the obese. Now, if I ran a restaurant, there are people who might suggest need to go elsewhere. But that does not seem to me to be the government's job, anymore than it is their job to tell you who many children to have, what position to have sex in, or whether or not you are allowed to have cookies in the house or not.

Government health insurance is going to inevitably lead to all sorts of bizarre struggles about what is to be allowed, what is to be banned--and what is to be required. For some people, a big family is a blessing from God. For others, it's a weird and somewhat freakish form of genetic imperialism. I'm sure that if the federal government becomes the single health insurer, as many Democrats want, there will be calls from the ZPG crowd to insist that the government only pays for the first two children.

If I have to pay for liver transplants for alcoholics--I am going to insist (not that anyone will listen to me) that the government prohibit these alcoholics from drinking. If I have to pay for medical care for the obese, it is perfectly understandable that the government start telling restaurants that they can't serve the obese. If we have to pay for AIDS treatment, which is very expensive, it is perfectly reasonable to insist that you don't engage in risky behavior.

Having the government be the ultimate insurance company means "one noose, one neck." We are all in this together. At best, we end up paying an increasingly absurd amount of money to deal with bad lifestyle choices. At worst, we end up with an increasingly authoritarian level of control over personal choices.

Disappointing Errors in Serious Books

Disappointing Errors in Serious Books

Irving B. Weiner, Donald K. Freedheim, John A. Schinka, Wayne F. Velicer, Michela Gallagher, Randy Joe Nelson, Alice F. Healy, Robert W. Proctor, Theodore Millon, Richard M. Lerner, M. Ann Easterbrooks, Jayanthi Mistry, William Michael Reynolds, Gloria E. Miller, Handbook of Psychology (John Wiley & Sons, 2003), 434, tells us that because of a shortage of mental health care being received by mental patients::
In 1968 the Lanterman Petris Short Bill was passed by Congress to address this concern....
How many errors can you get in a single sentence? Let's rewrite this to match the facts:
In 1967 the Lanterman-Petris-Short bill was passed by the California legislature...
And LPS wasn't passed by to address the shortage of mental health care at all. It was passed to institute a more exacting due process requirement for commitment, thus emptying the state mental hospitals. The net effect was not to improve provision of mental health care, but to move those who were hospitalized back into the community--where for the most part, they ended up living on the streets, and not getting mental health care.

I am just flabbergasted that what is apparently a serious standard work could have an error this gross. On the same page, they refer to 1957 Short-Doyle Act, and recognize that this was passed by the California legislature. You would think that the presence of Short's name in both acts might have caused someone to ask some questions.

Heated Driveways

The snow is deep enough today that even the Trailblazer might not make it out--or if it did, might not make it back up. And the snowthrower is in the shop. So today will be spent reading Henry F. Buswell, The Law of Insanity In Its Application to the Civil Rights and Capacities and Criminal Responsibility of the Citizen (Boston: Little, Brown & Co., 1885) for nuggets useful to the next book.

Heated driveways typically cost about $10 to $15 per square foot in addition to the cost of paving. If you have a traditional suburban driveway, that's a few thousand dollars--a very tempting expenditure. But if you have a driveway that is 600 feet long (like mine), that's
at least $60,000. You can buy a beat up pickup or a new ATV, put a snowplow on it, and buy enough gasoline to run that plow for decades without even getting close to that kind of money.

I think we'll plan on having asphalt poured this summer, and then get an ATV and snowplow.

Saturday, February 2, 2008

24: An Addiction & Ruminations on Torture

24: An Addiction & Ruminations on Torture

There aren't terribly many TV shows that I watch, and generally, they aren't shows on broadcast TV. I'm a big fan of Mythbusters. History Channel and Discovery Channel both have some quite well done shows--and occasionally, some real disappointments.

My impression of History Channel has gone up a bit over the last five years. I used to often find myself watching documentaries on History Channel and finding lots of either minor errors or at least highly arguable interpretations. And not just in my area of specialization. I don't know if I am getting less demanding (not likely), or if they are getting better at what they choose to air. It is still generally fluff, but more accurate fluff than I recall back in 2001.

One of the cable channels was running re-runs of 24 a couple of years back, and I ended up watching parts of seasons three and four--and it was addictive. My wife bought seasons one and two for my birthday, and now we are watching season four.

If you haven't watched the show, there are several aspects that are unique. The format is that every episode covers one hour of a 24 hour day in the life of the Los Angeles office of the fictional Counter Terrorism Unit, as they respond to some crisis. They make some use of multiple screen images so you see stuff that is happening to different characters in disparate locations. The editing (at least of the three seasons that I have seen so far) is absolutely brilliant, and the use of musical score to set mood is outstanding.

There are some aspects of the show that are profoundly depressing and gritty. I would like to think that there is more torture by government agents in 24 than there is in real life, but with what we know of waterboarding at places like Gitmo--maybe it isn't as far off as I would like to think.

What I find powerful about 24's depiction of torture is that I suspect that it at least partly reflects what goes on in the real world--where people on our side do some pretty ugly things to get necessary information about terrorist plans. These are actions that most Americans would not want to know about, because it is horrible--but that are probably sometimes necessary to prevent great losses of life. And by torture, I don't mean playing Christina Aguilar music to prisoners at Gitmo.

While 24 definitely has a good guys/bad guys dichotomy, it also has unpleasant reminders of the dangers of the use of torture. Once you cross the line into accepting the use of abusive techniques for getting information from bad guys, it is possible to make mistakes--sometimes very serious mistakes--about who is a bad guy. Season four has a couple of episodes that confront some of the consequences of getting too relaxed.

This is a show that is pretty tough to watch in places. There are a number of torture sequences that are not terribly graphic, but any reasonably intelligent adult can put two and two together and realize what is implied--and it can be pretty unpleasant to think about.

I would like to think that in the real world, the use of torture against suspected terrorists is rare, limited to suspects who are unquestionably terrorists, and limited to the minimum necessary level of suffering required to accomplish that end. I would also not be surprised if much of the use of torture is in the style of medieval torturers, who often were able to elicit information by merely showing the instruments of torture.

To the extent that well-meaning sorts like John McCain want to make it clear that certain interrogation techniques will never be used by the United States, it creates a situation where this threat will not work. Indeed, putting terrorists on notice that we will not use torture may oddly enough create situations where we may have to actually use torture as part of interrogation. If a terrorist believes that the CIA is utterly precluded from using torture, the threat won't be persuasive; only the actual infliction of suffering will accomplish those ends.

One aspect to 24 that I find frustrating is that much of the technology you see is almost real. Yes, there are an enormous number of traffic cameras and surveillance cameras out there. The full extent of how much America was already under surveillance came out in Timothy McVeigh's trial, when it turned out that there was a surprising amount of video coverage of many events involved in the case.

On the other hand, the vast majority of the surveillance cameras out there simply don't have the resolution to do what we see done. You can't take your average 640x480 video camera output, zoom in 20x on the license plate on a moving car, and really expect to have a crisp, easy to read plate. There are some astonishingly crisp satellite images that are taken by the KH-12 and similar spy satellites, but they are in low orbits that are moving more than four miles per second. They can't take dozens of images of the same location a second or two apart.

Much of the computer and network jargon is also utterly bogus--just close enough to the real thing that it sounds like it might be real, except if you know much about how computer and telecommunications networks actually work. Then it is just laughable! While I'm not current on telephone tracing technology, I'm pretty sure that most of the problems that our intrepid heroes in 24 have with tracing terrorist phone calls is grossly inaccurate. The transition from analog to digital telephone systems has dramatically changed this situation. I worked for a company many years ago that was requested as part of surveillance efforts to add certain capabilities to our switching equipment for law enforcement purposes, and I'm sure by now, trace time is measured not in minutes, but in fractions of a second.

On the human side, 24 has some very strong points, and some very weak points. It shows human behavior at its worst (petty, jealous, pigheaded, greedy) and at its best--such as the willingness of CTU employees to sacrifice themselves for the greater good. Make no mistake about it--America has no shortage of men and women who put themselves in harm's way for our safety, in military service, in law enforcement, and in real world organizations not so different from 24's CTU. Sometimes they are everything we think of as honorable and wonderful; sometimes they are people doing dirty jobs that we don't want to examine too closely. As George Orwell observed, "People sleep peaceably in their beds at night only because rough men stand ready to do violence on their behalf."

On the downside, there are aspects to 24 that I find silly or unrealistic. Our hero Jack Bauer is too fearless, too resourceful, too strong, too capable. He is not without his faults, but in the real world, no one is that good. In the real world, teams of real people accomplish things that 24's Jack Bauer does all by himself. In the first two seasons, so much of the plot was wrapped around the ability of Bauer's daughter to get herself repeatedly into hazardous situations that I found myself thinking of Snidely Whiplash and Nell tied up on the railroad tracks.

One plot device that 24 overuses involves good people who do wrong things because the bad guys have taken family members hostage. In the real world, especially in the Middle East, this happens a lot. Perhaps if George Soros, the ACLU, and friends get their way, this will become common in America as well. But it isn't realistic now. Most people who work in sensitive occupations, such as law enforcement, work pretty hard to keep their families secure and information about them hard to get.

The other aspect of this that shows 24 is letting dramatic license take over is that almost anyone in counterterrorism work has to know that there will be no fair deals made. If someone takes your family hostage, the chances that they will be allowed to go free--with information that might lead to a later capture and conviction of the hostage takers--is about zero.

There is one other aspect of the show that bothers me a lot. The second season--which was filmed after 9/11 but before the invasion of Iraq--had a premise involving European and American businessmen helping terrorists to set off a nuclear weapon in the U.S. to provoke a war in the Middle East--in order to drive up oil prices. It is so Michael Moore. There are other subplots in season three that also have evil businessmen involved as well. While there are Americans who have become involved with terrorist activities, here and abroad, they have, to my knowledge, always been driven by their religion, and never by greed. This bothers me, because it tends to blur what is the core of the terrorist threat that the U.S. faces.

On the plus side, 24 doesn't pretend that our enemies are Russians, or Norwegians, or Jews. (Although season one, filmed before 9/11, involves Serbians, and season three is largely built around Mexican drug lords.) While not heavy handed, seasons two and four are clearly Middle Eastern Muslim fanatics, some of whom are sleeper cells.