Monday, December 3, 2007

Shear Stress of Bolts

Shear Stress of Bolts

Big Bertha's rebuild will be mounted on what is called a dovetail plate, which slides into the saddle of the Losmandy mount. There are then two large screws (on the CI-700 mount) that tighten down against the dovetail plate, preventing motion.

How does the dovetail plate attach to the telescope? Usually, this is done with some screws that go up through the bottom of the dovetail plate, and screw into the telescope tube, or a ring that holds the telescope tube. For Big Bertha 2.0, this is going to be screwed into a tapped hole in the square aluminum tubing that holds the components in place.

But these are typically 1/4"-20 screws that hold telescopes to the dovetail. Will that be strong enough? I have become intoxicated with the power of computing this stuff, like a mechanical engineer would do, and so I decided to try and compute it.

The definition of shear stress is the force per unit area that will cause a material to fail and that "act over an area which is in line with the forces." To compute the force that will cause a bolt or screw to fail, you compute its area, and then compare the force applied across that screw to the shear strength.

For a 1/4" bolt, that's roughly (.00635^2) square meters. The shear strength of stainless steel is approximately 186 MPa (megapascals). This means that to shear a stainless steel bolt of that size would require about 7500 Newtons. (A Newton is one kilogram accelerating at 1 m/sec^2. Use 9.8 m/sec^2 as the force of gravity to compute the force on this planet.) For weight alone to shear the bolt would therefore require a bit more than 765 kilograms (or about 1684 pounds).

There are two bolts that will hold Big Bertha 2.0 to the dovetail plate, and from what I have read, the stress is divided by the number of bolts (although I can see how in some positions, one bolt might get all the load).

Big Bertha 2.0 is only going to weigh about 60 pounds. I think I'm safe using two 1/4"-20 bolts!

UPDATE: A reader whose signature line indicates that he is a mechanical engineer working on commercial jetliner landing struts points out that:

1. A fully thread bolt's shear cross section is a smaller than the nominal diameter. I presume that this is because the minor diameter of the thread (the bottom of the threads) is a good bit smaller than the major diameter of the thread (which is about the nominal diameter).

2. He thought the numbers above for the shear strength of stainless bolts was a bit low--although he also pointed out that most of the bolts that you actually buy at a hardware store are less than perfect chunks of steel.

3. Apparently it is considered good rule of thumb to assume that only half the bolts holding an assembly in place actually are carrying the load. This is not surprising; as I pointed out above, depending on position and angle, the load may be disproportionately on one bolt, instead of evenly distributed.

He still thinks that two 1/4"-20 bolts will more than do the job.

UPDATE 2: Another reader points to these two pages for finding strength of various bolts, one of which shows strengths for various grades of bolts, and the other shows minor diameter of various threads, and area. The weakest grade of bolt (ASTM A320 Grade 8) in 1/4"-20 shows a yield strength of 954 pounds. It might be tempting when the time comes to buy two of the higher grades of bolts, which will take the yield strength in that size up into the 2000 pound range.

UPDATE 3: The shear strength of bolts is typically about 55% of the yield strength.

A Short Sigh of Relief

The latest National Intelligence Estimate concludes that Iran, which was working on developing nuclear weapons some years back--stopped in 2003. From the December 3, 2007 New York Times:
WASHINGTON, Dec. 3 — A new assessment by American intelligence agencies concludes that Iran halted its nuclear weapons program in 2003 and that the program remains on hold, contradicting an assessment two years ago that Tehran was working inexorably toward building a bomb.

The conclusions of the new assessment are likely to be major factor in the tense international negotiations aimed at getting Iran to halt its nuclear energy program. Concerns about Iran were raised sharply after President Bush had suggested in October that a nuclear-armed Iran could lead to “World War III,” and Vice President Dick Cheney promised “serious consequences” if the government in Tehran did not abandon its nuclear program.

The findings also come in the middle of a presidential campaign during which a possible military strike against Iran’s nuclear program has been discussed.

The assessment, a National Intelligence Estimate that represents the consensus view of all 16 American spy agencies, states that Tehran’s ultimate intentions about gaining a nuclear weapon remain unclear, but that Iran’s “decisions are guided by a cost-benefit approach rather than a rush to a weapon irrespective of the political, economic and military costs.”

“Some combination of threats of intensified international scrutiny and pressures, along with opportunities for Iran to achieve its security, prestige, and goals for regional influence in other ways might — if perceived by Iran’s leaders as credible — prompt Tehran to extend the current halt to its nuclear weapons program,” the estimate states.
Instapundit suggests that something else happened in 2003 that might have changed Iranian ambitions. Perhaps he means, "We invaded Iraq, and scared Iran witless."

Or perhaps (and this is my guess), Iran was developing WMDs because they were afraid that Iraq was doing so (just like we thought Iraq was doing). Without the prospect of a nuclear-armed Iraq, Iran might well have decided that they had better things to spend their money on.

Of course, if Iran did stop development of nuclear weapons because we invaded Iraq, this would be an example of a positive unintended consequence. But Bush, the U.S., and the Coalition of the Willing, won't get any credit for it, you can be sure.

Idaho Soldier Welcomed Home

This is one of those news stories that just takes your breath away. Not because the people of his hometown, Sandpoint, organized a big celebration for his return. That's a good thing, but not surprising. From the December 3, 2007 Idaho Statesman:
SANDPOINT - Christin Anderson, a longtime resident of this North Idaho town, has never met U.S. Army Sgt. Brandon Adam.

But that didn't stop her from standing alongside U.S. 95 Sunday in below-freezing temperatures, waving an American flag while her husband, Andrew, held up a sign that read "Thanks Sarge and Welcome Home."

The Andersons were among hundreds of Sandpoint-area residents who lined up along city streets with red, white and blue balloons to celebrate the homecoming of 22-year-old Adam, a Sandpoint High School graduate and Purple Heart recipient who lost both of his legs in May while on a second tour in Iraq.

"It's so moving to know that he is one of the many willing to do so much for us," Anderson said.

Adam's Thanksgiving trip home to see his parents, Doug and Karen Adam of Post Falls, is the first since the accident.

"It's pretty overwhelming and humbling," Adam said of the community's response.

Adam was a combat engineer stationed with the 2nd Infantry in Fort Carson, Colo. He was in the middle of his second tour and had recently signed up for a third when the accident occurred.

The Sept. 11, 2001, terror attacks inspired him to enlist; he reported for duty right out of high school.

Sandpoint resident Marsha Ogilvie and Adam's sister, Trish Small, were the driving force behind his homecoming celebration. Ogilvie said she saw a program on television about a group of World War II veterans that started meeting injured soldiers coming home from Iraq at the airport.
No, what takes your breath away is how this young man has responded to a catastrophic loss. If there is anyone who has a right to be bitter, or angry, about the Iraq War, it would be this guy:
After the roadside bomb explosion in Baghdad that claimed both of his legs below the knee, Adam was evacuated first to Germany, then to the Brooke Army Medical Center at Fort Sam Houston near San Antonio, Texas, where he has been recovering since.

In early November, Adam had the opportunity to meet President George W. Bush, who toured the Center for the Intrepid, a new $50 million physical rehabilitation center at the hospital.

"I was in therapy and then they said we couldn't leave," Adam said. Then the press arrived, as did the secret service.

Adam described Bush as a "regular guy" who made small talk with the soldier and seemed "compassionate" about the injured men.

...

Adam hopes to be up and about again soon. His prosthetic legs are being fit in increments, and Adam said he's nearly back to his 6-foot stature. He's working with legs that make him 5-foot-6 right now.

Adam wants to join Olympic wheelchair events, has a ski trip planned and recently went surfing in Pismo Beach, Calif. He wants to go to college to study business or film editing.

His disability is not going to hold him back, he said.

"It did for a minute, then I thought about it and got over it," Adam said. "You can't let anything dictate your life."
I hear far more anger and bitterness from antiwar activists who have given up nothing.

One of the most troubling aspects to war is that we lose--or damage--our most idealistic and courageous people. Some die; some lose limbs; a fair number come home with PTSD or lesser mental disturbances caused by war.

Over time, these individual costs turn into an enormous cost to the society. I don't just mean the costs of rehab and artificial limbs. I mean the costs to a society that rewards those who don't answer the call to duty. I still can't support a draft--but I do think that raising the pay for military would be a good thing, to more properly reward those who are doing a very risky and necessary function.

CNN had a special recently about the problems that veterans are experiencing with the Veterans Administration. There was one guy with a missing arm who had been fighting with the VA about how much of his injuries were service-related. Now, there are times where it is difficult to figure out whether a particular psychological problem or long-term illness is the result of military service--or might have happened anyway. They showed a letter from the VA that claimed that this guy's "shrapnel all over his body" was not "service-related." Huh? Even worse, whoever was responsible for sending out the letter had cut his name and signature block out of the letter--almost like someone was ashamed to send a letter this absurd. (He should have been ashamed--enough to make him rethink sending out a letter like that.)

There was another guy who had been severely burned as a result of an IED. It was obvious that a lot of plastic surgery had been done on the guy's face--and he was still grotesque. (World War I was the first war to produce large numbers of veterans without faces--much worse, by the way, than this guy.) All I could think was, "Is this the best job that the VA's plastic surgeons could do?"

If the Democrats are all hot to raise taxes to keep upper middle class people from competing with them for land in Sun Valley (where billionaires are pushing out millionaires), spending a bit more on military pay and helping returning veterans would make a lot more sense.

Sunday, December 2, 2007

Additions to the FBI's Gun Background Check System

Nikki Fellenzer points to this Washington Post article about the expansion of the National Information Background Check System:
Justice officials said the FBI's "Mental Defective File" has ballooned from 175,000 names in June to nearly 400,000, primarily because of additions from California. The names are listed in a subset of a database that gun dealers are supposed to check before completing sales.

The surge in names underscores the size of the gap in FBI records that allowed Seung Hui Cho to purchase the handguns he used in April to kill 32 people and himself at the Virginia Tech campus in Blacksburg.

A Virginia state court found Cho to be dangerously mentally ill in 2005 and ordered him to receive outpatient treatment. But because Cho was not ordered into hospital treatment, the court's order was never provided to the FBI and incorporated in its database. Two gun dealers checked the list before selling Cho the 9mm Glock 19 and the Walther .22-caliber pistol he used in the shootings.

For nearly four decades, federal law has prohibited gun sales to people judged to be "mentally defective," but enforcement has been haphazard. A 1995 Supreme Court ruling barred the federal government from forcing states to provide the data, and 18 states -- including Delaware and West Virginia -- provide no mental health-related information to the FBI at all. Both Virginia and Maryland do provide the data.
Nikki doesn't see that this expansion of the list does much good:
How easy is it to get one's hands on a gun if 80 percent of the ones used in crimes are obtained illegally? Ever heard of a black market?
She has a very good point with respect to convicted felons, who have all sorts of sources for guns--for a price. But people who have been declared mentally incompetent (usually for psychosis, not retardation) are in a rather different situation.

Some of them are so obviously crazy that a gun store wouldn't sell them a gun, no matter what. My guess is that relatively few of the black market sources for guns would do so either--for fear that such a person might use the gun on the seller.

Others may go through episodes where they are obviously psychotic, interrupted by periods of apparent sanity. Someone like Cho Seung-Hui was not obviously psychotic--and yet was, even before the massacre, severely enough disturbed that it was obvious to those who knew him that he was not right in the head. I suspect that many of the informal sources of guns that we lump together as "black market" (which includes friends, relatives, someone you met at a party) would have been reluctant to sell to Cho Seung-Hui simply because he was a bit odd.

Let's not kid ourselves that the background check system works perfectly. Like all systems, it works at the margins. It may prevent 10-15% of the mentally ill from buying a gun from a dealer. It may slow down how rapidly another 5-10% of the mentally ill obtain a gun. Is this a good thing? Yes. A system doesn't have to work perfectly to still be of value. As long as the system prevents some prohibited buyers from getting guns, and delays some prohibited buyers from getting guns--without impairing lawful purchasers from buying guns--that's a good thing.

There comes a point where you have to look at the costs. If keeping a gun out of a mental patient's hands costs the government $1, I think we can immediately see this as a reasonable expenditure. If it costs $100,000 for every gun we keep out of a mental patient's hands, I think we can spend the money more wisely. Perhaps that $100,000 could be more usefully spent fixing our incredibly broken mental health system, for example, so that psychotics receive treatment, instead of wandering the streets until they decide that they are Emperor of Colorado, and try to stage a coup using a handgun. But the mere fact that some states are actually beginning to report those who have been involuntarily committed is not necessarily a problem.

Wanted: Scratched or Broken 48mm Camera Filters

Since I can't seem to find a tap for cutting 48mm camera filter threads, if you have any scratched or broken 48mm camera filters (as long as the threads are okay), I would love to have them. I can buy new filters for about $2.50 each, but it seems silly to break perfectly good filters if you have four or five of them that have damaged glass.

Senator Happy Feet Needs To Go

The December 2, 2007 Idaho Statesman has this sad little report:
David Phillips. Mike Jones. Greg Ruth. Tom Russell.

Four gay men, willing to put their names in print and whose allegations can't be disproved, have come forward since news of U.S. Sen. Larry Craig's guilty plea. They say they had sex with Craig or that he made a sexual advance or that he paid them unusual attention.

They are telling their stories now because they are offended by Craig's denials, including his famous statement, "I am not gay, I never have been gay." Those words, spoken on live national TV on Aug. 28, are now memorialized on a just-released-for-Christmas Talking Senator Larry Craig Action Figure.

David Phillips is a 42-year-old information technology consultant in Washington, D.C., who says Craig picked him up at a gay club in 1986 and that they subsequently had sex.

Mike Jones is a former prostitute who told the world he had sex with the Rev. Ted Haggard last year. The former Colorado Springs evangelist at first denied it but eventually confessed. Jones says Craig paid him for sex in late 2004 or early 2005.

Greg Ruth was a 24-year-old college Republican in 1981 when he says he was hit on by Craig at a Republican meeting in Coeur d'Alene.

Tom Russell, now 48, is a former Nampa resident who lives in Utah. Russell said his encounter with Craig occurred at Bogus Basin in the early 1980s.

A fifth gay man, who is from Boise but who declined to be named for fear of retaliation, offered a recent and telling account: He was in a men's restroom at Denver International Airport in September 2006 when the man in the next stall moved his hand slowly, palm up, under the divider. Alarmed, the man said he waited outside the restroom and then identified the man in the adjoining stall as Craig, whom he had met in Idaho.
The rest of the story is full of sordid materials that I won't quote here--but it is the sort of casual sex with strangers that is a big part of gay life, as much as Hollywood wants you to believe otherwise.

Senator Happy Feet needs to go.

Another Fake Hate Crime

Another Fake Hate Crime

From December 1, 2007 WJZ channel 13 in Baltimore:
BALTIMORE (AP) ― The Baltimore Fire Department has suspended a paramedic apprentice who admitted placing a threatening note and a rope shaped like a noose inside a firehouse.

Fire officials say the paramedic, Gary Maynard, is the one who initially reported finding the note and the rope. Fire department spokesman Kevin Cartwright says Maynard confessed to city police that he left the note and the rope.

A statement from Fire Chief William Goodwin says Maynard's scheme was "meant to create the perception that members within our department were acting in a discriminatory and unprofessional manner."
There are so many of these hate crimes that turn out to be fakes--it makes you wonder how many of the rest are just better done fakes.