Sunday, December 2, 2007

The New Chief Judge of the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals

It is Alex Kozinski--a conservative judge who grew up under Communism, and not surprisingly, is strongly in support of the individual rights view of the Second Amendment. The November 30, 2007 Los Angeles Times describes his new responsibilities:
he chief judge has overall responsibility for circuit operations -- basically ensuring the expeditious, inexpensive and fair disposition of appeals -- and is the court's public face. The chief judge also heads the Circuit Judicial Council, the court's policymaking arm; represents the 9th Circuit on the Judicial Conference, which makes policy for the entire federal judiciary; and represents the 9th Circuit in its dealings with Congress. The chief judge is the only one of the circuit's judges who always serves on the court's "en banc" panels that rehear many of the most controversial and important appeals.

...

Kozinski, nearly a decade younger than Schroeder, enjoys a well-deserved reputation as an iconoclast or, some would say, eccentric. Born to Holocaust survivors in Bucharest, Romania, Kozinski came to the U.S. at age 12. He grew up in Los Angeles, attending Marshall High School and UCLA before clerking for then-9th Circuit Judge Anthony Kennedy and U.S. Chief Justice Warren Burger. In the early 1980s, President Reagan appointed Kozinski as chief judge of the new U.S. Claims Court, and in 1985, Reagan appointed him to the 9th Circuit, making him the nation's youngest appellate judge.

Still, the "conservative" label does not quite capture Kozinski's jurisprudential views. He has said that a conservative president appointed him and that he tends "to have conservative instincts" but also believes strongly "in important principles of freedom" -- freedom of speech, religion and personal privacy. He once famously explained the 9th Circuit's judicial independence by remarking that its judges were three time zones away from the Supreme Court and the nation's capital.
This article from Capitalism magazine reprints part of one of Kozinski's dissents in 2003:
Judges know very well how to read the Constitution broadly when they are sympathetic to the right being asserted. We have held, without much ado, that "speech, or . . . the press" also means the Internet, and that "persons, houses, papers, and effects" also means public telephone booths. When a particular right comports especially well with our notions of good social policy, we build magnificent legal edifices on elliptical constitutional phrases--or even the white spaces between lines of constitutional text. But, as the panel amply demonstrates, when we're none too keen on a particular constitutional guarantee, we can be equally ingenious in burying language that is incontrovertibly there.

It is wrong to use some constitutional provisions as spring-boards for major social change while treating others like senile relatives to be cooped up in a nursing home until they quit annoying us. As guardians of the Constitution, we must be consistent in interpreting its provisions. If we adopt a jurisprudence sympathetic to individual rights, we must give broad compass to all constitutional provisions that protect individuals from tyranny. If we take a more statist approach, we must give all such provisions narrow scope. Expanding some to gargantuan proportions while discarding others like a crumpled gum wrapper is not faithfully applying the Constitution; it's using our power as federal judges to constitutionalize our personal preferences.

The able judges of the panel majority are usually very sympathetic to individual rights, but they have succumbed to the temptation to pick and choose. Had they brought the same generous approach to the Second Amendment that they routinely bring to the First, Fourth and selected portions of the Fifth, they would have had no trouble finding an individual right to bear arms. Indeed, to conclude otherwise, they had to ignore binding precedent. United States v. Miller (1939) did not hold that the defendants lacked standing to raise a Second Amendment defense, even though the government argued the collective rights theory in its brief. The Supreme Court reached the Second Amendment claim and rejected it on the merits after finding no evidence that Miller's weapon--a sawed-off shotgun--was reasonably susceptible to militia use. We are bound not only by the outcome of Miller but also by its rationale. If Miller's claim was dead on arrival because it was raised by a person rather than a state, why would the Court have bothered discussing whether a sawed-off shotgun was suitable for militia use? The panel majority not only ignores Miller's test; it renders most of the opinion wholly superfluous. As an inferior court, we may not tell the Supreme Court it was out to lunch when it last visited a constitutional provision.

The majority falls prey to the delusion--popular in some circles--that ordinary people are too careless and stupid to own guns, and we would be far better off leaving all weapons in the hands of professionals on the government payroll. But the simple truth--born of experience--is that tyranny thrives best where government need not fear the wrath of an armed people. Our own sorry history bears this out: Disarmament was the tool of choice for subjugating both slaves and free blacks in the South. In Florida, patrols searched blacks' homes for weapons, confiscated those found and punished their owners without judicial process. In the North, by contrast, blacks exercised their right to bear arms to defend against racial mob violence. As Chief Justice Taney well appreciated, the institution of slavery required a class of people who lacked the means to resist. See Dred Scott v. Sandford, (1857) (finding black citizenship unthinkable because it would give blacks the right to "keep and carry arms wherever they went"). A revolt by Nat Turner and a few dozen other armed blacks could be put down without much difficulty; one by four million armed blacks would have meant big trouble.

Saturday, December 1, 2007

The Advantages of Having a Lathe

The Advantages of Having a Lathe

I think I mentioned previously that the Chromacor is a very cool gadget that turns a so-so achromatic refractor into a well-corrected apochromat--but that because the Chromacor screws into the threaded barrel of diagonal assembly on the refractor, there's no way to use the Chromacor without the diagonal in place. This is a problem, because the diagonal adds several inches to the optical path, making it impossible for me to attach my camera to the telescope without removing the diagonal--and thus, the Chromacor.

I decided to fix this, so I turned a piece of Delrin that replaces the diagonal. Since the 48mm threads are not a common tap (and I don't have a thread cutting attachment for the lathe), I bored out the interior end of the Delrin so that I can press fit a 48mm threaded filter in place. (I'll epoxy it in place for permanence.) Now I can screw the Chromacor onto the filter, and put it into the telescope without the diagonal. I now have the advantages of the Chromacor with the option of astrophotography!

I didn't have a big enough piece of aluminum lying about; perhaps I'm look into making them out of aluminum for the ultimate niche market--Chromacor owners!

Continual Revision of the Big Bertha Redesign

Continual Revision of the Big Bertha Redesign

It turns out that Big Bertha's current diagonal mirror is larger than it should be (reducing image quality and light)--4.25". It turns out that if I reduce the mirror size to 3.1"--and increase tube diameter to 20.4" from 20"--I can get a nearly optimum combination of full illumination of the eyepiece and minimal obstruction. Of course, that means slightly enlarging the base plate the mirror cell (which I have not yet ordered), which increases the weight by a few ounces, and the weight of the two tube assemblies by an ounce or two. On the other hand, a 3.1" diagonal mirror is much lighter than the current diagonal.

However: my choices on the square tubes that hold the tube ends apart are becoming frustrating. I had plugged in the wrong value for Young's modulus--using the stiffness of carbon fiber composite instead of aluminum. Now my choices are to go to a larger, considerably heavier set of aluminum square tubes, or spend the money on carbon fiber composite. The net effect is that using 1", .125" wall aluminum square tube gives me a total telescope weight of 67 pounds to get the total deflection down into the thousandths of an inch range--just too heavy. Going to .995", .060" wall carbon fiber composite gets me a 48 pound telescope with a comparable worst case deflection down below .004". The price of this stuff, however, is breathtaking--like $400 for the four tubes. Unless, of course, you know of a surplus carbon fiber composite dealer...

Of course, I may be going too far on this. The deflection calculations are for the worst case--the telescope is pointing at the horizon. In practice, there is probably enough flex in a solid telescope tube that perhaps I can accept a few hundredths of an inch of deflection. I suppose that the worst that happens is I use somewhat smaller aluminum square tube (or two instead of four). For two square tubes, this gives me a total telescope weight of 57 pounds, and a maximum deflection of .014". If I need to, I suppose that I can add two more tubes.

Astrophotography At 20 Degrees

Beautifully clear last night--and incredibly cold because of it. (Okay, those of you in the Dakotas would probably be putting on swimsuits for 20 degree weather--but for me, a Southern California boy, this was cold.)

The comet is showing more and more tail. It is still pretty subtle, but you can see that there is more than just a single fuzzy blob to it. I also used the 8" f/7 reflector this time--and unsurprisingly, it showed a lot more detail than the refractor. (More light.)

Unfortunately, my attempts at taking pictures weren't so successful. I wasn't aimed as precisely on celestial north, and I wasn't prepared to spend the time getting properly aimed. Way too cold!

Mars is bright, and there's a very noticeable disc (even at 45x), but it is still too low in the sky to get much detail yet.

Why Fred Thompson Isn't Going Anywhere

This is a painful November 30, 2007 Wall Street Journalarticle, because it is obvious that Kim Strassel has the same high opinion of Fred Thompson that I do--and why Thompson's campaign is turning out to be a complete bust in spite of a lot of very good proposals from Thompson:
On Fox News this Sunday, Fred Thompson laid out the most creative tax proposal yet in the race for president. It should have been an important moment, the point at which GOP aspirants finally dug into a core issue and went a few rounds over marginal rates and corporate levies.

Instead, nothing. The Thompson plan inspired little fanfare, less press and didn't even merit time during this week's GOP debate. The black hole says everything about the mess that is the Thompson campaign, and just as much about today's intellectually bereft Republican primary campaign.

The standard rap on the former Tennessee senator is that he's lazy. This is meant to explain why--despite movie-star status, Southern conservative credentials, and Beltway experience--his campaign has been as fizzy as day-old cherry Coke. The reality is more complex--and more concerning for Mr. Thompson's presidential prospects.

The Watergate attorney has made himself into this election's Don Quixote, the impractical idealist tilting at "the system." Even as he announced his run on the Jay Leno show in September, Mr. Thompson quipped he "wasn't in the room when they made the rules" that resulted in today's sped up, big-money, 24-hour-news-byte primary. He has refused to play nice--declaring late and declining to join rivals in the media hoopla and nonstop campaign. It has proven a case study in the folly of trying to single-handedly buck modern politics.

It might have helped if Mr. Thompson, who stated his intention to trust in "the people" to give him a hearing, had offered those people something more than personality at the start of his tardy campaign. It has instead only been very recently that he has, admirably, tried to craft himself into the ideas candidate.

He's proposed revitalizing America's armed forces by increasing the core defense budget, building up a million-member ground force, and instituting sweeping missile defense. He went where no other GOP candidate has yet gone with a detailed plan to shore up Social Security, by changing the benefits formula and offering voluntary "add on" accounts for younger workers. He would re-energize school vouchers. His border security blueprint certainly matches Mitt Romney's or Rudy Giuliani's in its, ahem, creativity and thoroughness.

This week's tax proposal was decidedly fresh, going beyond the run-of-the-mill candidate promise to extend the Bush tax cuts, and calling for the end of the death tax and the AMT, a cut in the corporate tax rate and even a voluntary flat tax. According to a campaign source, in upcoming weeks Mr. Thompson will unveil plans to reduce federal spending by limiting nondefense growth to inflation, earmark reform, and a one-year freeze on the hiring of non-essential civilian workers and contractors.

There's plenty here to get conservative voters and bloggers and pundits engaged in some healthy, even lively, debate. That is, if they'd heard any of this. Most haven't, and for that Mr. Thompson has mostly himself to blame.
The fundraising envelope from Thompson's campaign is in the bill drawer, scheduled for the middle of the month. But if Thompson's campaign doesn't start to catch fire before I get down to that bill, the temptation will be strong to hold onto that money for a Congressional or Senate campaign that shows a bit more ability to make something happen.

This Might Cheer You Up

These online polls don't mean much at all, because they aren't proper samples, and it is very easy for one side or the other to spread the word quickly to get their side to participate, but USA Today asked the following question:

"Does the Second Amendment give individuals the right to bear arms?"

As of right now, they have recorded 17,844 votes. Yes: 98%. No: 1%. Undecided: 0%.

Mental Health & Politics

"Republicans Report Much Better Mental Health Than Others"

I am going to resist the urge to make a snarky remark about this Gallup survey that finds that Republicans are more likely than Democrats or independents to have excellent mental health. There is a substantive issue here--and the multivariate correlation analysis Gallup did suggests that Gallup found the results so amazing that they felt a need to figure out why.

PRINCETON, NJ -- Republicans are significantly more likely than Democrats or independents to rate their mental health as excellent, according to data from the last four November Gallup Health and Healthcare polls. Fifty-eight percent of Republicans report having excellent mental health, compared to 43% of independents and 38% of Democrats. This relationship between party identification and reports of excellent mental health persists even within categories of income, age, gender, church attendance, and education.
On page 3 of the report they show that when you correlate mental health against other variables, there are several factors that seem important:
The table shows that income, education, gender, church attendance, and being a Republican are significantly related to self-reported mental health -- each such relationship occurring even when the impact of the other variables is taken into account.
The numbers show that income is by far the most important correlation. Whining socialists may decide, "Of course. Rich people don't have any reason to have mental health problems." But more likely, people who are severely depressed are more likely to have trouble holding jobs. It is easy to see how mental healthy people will have higher incomes for that reason.

Church attendance is the next most significant factor. Perhaps depression makes it hard to get out of bed on Sunday morning--but I would also find it plausible that a serious faith--one serious enough to get you to church with some regularity--might be a contributing factor to mental health.

Education came in next, somewhat after church attendance. This doesn't surprise me, again, because people with serious mental health problems are less likely to be able to complete college.

Being a Republican comes just after education. Do people with mental health problems identify with being Democrats? It seems rather difficult to see how mental illness would prevent you from being a Republican.

The only other statistically significant factor was gender, but I can't figure out from the article whether men or women were more likely to be mentally healthy.