Thursday, June 28, 2007

"You Can't Make An Omelet Without Breaking Some Eggs"

In the 1930s, intellectuals making excuses for censorship, police state, show trials, and mass murder, would use this expression as a jocular way of distracting attention from the Soviet Union's little...failings.

I think that I have found the modern equivalent.

Albert Brooks’ 1974 compendium of legal issues associated with mental illness speculated that if civil commitment went away as a mechanism for dealing with those who were everything from murderers to public disorder problems, that something else would take its place. His prediction turned out to be remarkably accurate:

It is assumed that if coercive commitment were abolished, most of the persons presently confined would not be confined, and would be either treated on an outpatient basis or simply left alone. It is more likely, however, that a probable consequence of abolishing civil commitment would be that persons who engage in undesirable behaviors now controlled by the civil process would become subject to our already overloaded criminal justice system, and would be treated as “criminals”…. [Brooks, Law, Psychiatry and the Mental Health System, 606.]

Two years earlier, M. F. Abramson, a psychiatrist who consulted “to a county jail system, county courts, and the adult division of a county probation department,” described the effects of California’s cutting edge Lanterman-Petris-Short Act (1969). While acknowledging that some of the effects were positive, “There may be a limit to society’s tolerance of mentally disordered behavior. … [M]entally disordered persons are being increasingly subjected to arrest and criminal prosecution.” Because so many of these deinstitutionalized or never-institutionalized mental patients were using illegal drugs, when they came to the attention of police, drug possession was likely the basis for processing them—but as criminals, not as persons in need of care. The state prison system was suddenly awash in mentally ill prisoners.[M.F. Abramson, “The Criminalization Of Mentally Disordered Behavior: Possible Side-Effect Of A New Mental Health Law,” Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 23[1972]:101-105.]\

Unsurprisingly, Abramson’s concerns were soon met with a response by a J. Monahan that argued that forcing mentally ill people into the criminal justice system was actually a good thing:

But the criminal justice system forces society to confront its tolerance level, to think out, evaluate, and agree upon exactly what behaviors are so deviant that their perpetrators should be incarcerated. By holding up for public debate in the courts and the legislature such issues as homosexuality, prostitution, abortion, and marijuana use—all of which have mental health aspects—the system forces society to come face to face with its norms and values.

Perhaps most disturbing is how this wonderful confrontation of society to deviance was couched not in terms of concern for the mentally ill offender—for Monahan admitted that “on a purely humane level mental hospitals may be preferable to jails in many jurisdictions”—but that the mental patients would bear the costs of confronting what Monahan clearly saw as a hypocritical and rigid society: “the current paradigm clash between criminal justice and mental health may be a portent of true progress, a sign that revolutionary advances in our ways of conceptualizing and responding to antisocial behavior are in the offing.” [J. Monahan, “The Psychiatrization Of Criminal Behavior: A Reply,” Hospital & Community Psychiatry, 24[1973]:105-107.]

And what a tragedy this wonderful theory has produced.
Gun Rights Policy Conference 2007

I'll be one of the speakers. If you are planning to attend, great! And if not: here are the details.
Advantages of a Conservative Plurality on the Supreme Court

They're willing to strike down racially discriminationary laws--at least when they are this gross. In today's decision Parents Involved In Community Schools v. Seattle School District No. 1 (2007) they ruled that assignment of students to schools strictly on the basis of race violates the Constitution--and they point to Brown v. Board of Education (1954). As the headnotes point out, a bit more articulately than Chief Justice Roberts' opinion, in Brown, it wasn't the inequality of the schools that was the legal problem, but that individuals were discriminated against based on race--and that's the problem with both the suits that were consolidated into this decision.

The Seattle case involved students applying to hard to get into public high schools; the school district decided who to assign to what school based on whether that student's race would advance their goals for racial balance--and as Roberts' opinion points out, the only race that matters is white vs. non-white. If "diversity" was the goal, they would have been concerned about more than just this crude distinction, and they would also have been concerned about socioeconomic class. Roberts' opinion points out that what made race a tolerable factor in the Grutter decision was that race was not the only factor. In addition, Seattle schools have never been racially segregated.

The Kentucky case involved a child who couldn't get into the elementary school one mile from his home because it was full. The district, again making a decision based solely on whether the child was black or not, offered an elementary school ten miles away--but refused the child's entrance into an elementary school that had openings, and was also one mile away. Again, race was the only factor in making the decision, and it reminds me of the absurdity of the bad old days when black kids might have to pass right by a neighborhood school because they were the wrong race.

Justice Thomas' concurring opinion points out that the liberal dissent was destroying the meaning of the word "segregation" when they claimed that racial discrimination was necessary to prevent "resegregation." He reminds the reader that the evil of segregation was not that some schools were majority black and some majority white, but that the law required that students be assigned to schools based on their race, treating every individual as simply a representative of whiteness or blackness. Thomas also quotes from many of the decisions of the Court from the 1960s and 1970s that insisted that school districts had to obey the law, and not assign students to schools based on their race.

Thomas also points to the hypocrisy of the Seattle district, which claims that racial balance is necessary--but runs a K-8 "African-American Academy" which is, unsurprisingly, 99% nonwhite.

Justice Stevens' dissent, of course, argues against strict scrutiny--which is really sad. Part of why we have "strict scrutiny" as a doctrine is because segregationists for many years had the best lawyers. Strict scrutiny became a mechanism for striking down discriminatory laws that would otherwise have survived less demanding standards. Now liberals are reduced to arguing against strict scrutiny with respect to race!

I'm disappointed with how opportunistic much of the Republican Party has become in the last year or two (the illegal immigrant amnesty, for example), but if there's any question about whether we need a Republican Senate and a Republican President, you need only look at a decision like this. Imagine if the last two Supreme Court justices had been appointed by a Democrat--I think we can say with some certainty that they would have approved treating students not as individuals, but as black and white chess pieces.

Wednesday, June 27, 2007

Idaho's Health and Human Services Budget

I had a chat with someone who told me that the legislature has again cut the budget for the Idaho Health and Human Services Department--so I decided to find out how heartless our legislature is.

Look on page 9 of this summary; it shows that Health & Human Services has increased spending from $772,100,000 to $1,719,200,000 between FY 1997 and FY 2007. CPI-U (consumer price index urban consumers) increased from 159.1 in January 1997 to 202.416 in January 2007--or about a 27% inflation in the value of the dollar. The 1997 population of Idaho was about 1.22 million; the 2006 population estimate (closest that I could find) was 1,466,465. That means that the 1997 Health & Human Services per capita spending, in 1997 dollars, was $632.86; the 2007 per capita spending, in 1997 dollars, was $923.10. That's a 45.9% increase in per capita spending, inflation adjusted, over the last ten years.

I'm not sure who told my friend that the legislature has been cutting the budget on this, but they are wrong. The 2008 budget request from the Health and Human Services Department was $1,800,035,700; the Governor's recommendation is $1,768,205,500. The Governor's request is 2.8% larger than last year, probably just enough to keep up with inflation and population growth.

Tuesday, June 26, 2007

Cross-Slide Vise (Again)

I mentioned last September that I had bought a cross-slide vise at Harbor Freight which had dials allowing you to move the X and Y directions in .1 mm increments, but I was a bit disappointed--it was at least 3% inaccurate. This was so far from accurate that it was hardly worth messing with.

Well, I was looking at it yesterday, and I suddenly noticed some screws on the side of both the X and Y stages--and decided to play with them a bit. They tighten up the play in both directions--and improve the accuracy.

When I was done fiddling, the X axis is now very accurate. I made 30 turns of the crank, and then measured the movement with a micrometer. It should have been 90 mm. It came to 89.93 mm--which is .2% accurate. There's more error in how I positioned the micrometer. The Y axis isn't quite as good, but 30 turns should have been 90 mm. It came to 89.45 mm--or .6% accurate.

I am now using this not just as a coarse positioning device, but as a sufficiently accurate method of positioning objects within a hundredth of an inch!
Irony Overload

The Sandusky, Ohio Register has just published a list of all Erie County residents with concealed handgun licenses. In the discussion forum attached to that article, there is a list of "Discussion Guidelines" (really rules) for use of the forum:
Likewise, you may not post content that is libelous, defamatory, obscene, abusive, that violates a third party's right to privacy....
But they will publish a complete list of the names, ages, and city of residence of people with carry permits--with predictable comments from creeps like this:
Mister Gash wrote on Jun 26, 2007 2:23 PM:
" KARA GROFF 21 ERIE NICOLE BEVERLY 23 ERIE TANA DEAN 25 ERIE Young coeds with handguns! This is a total turn-on! I wonder if they are so hot that they need to gun to beat off potential rapists!? "
Imagine if a newspaper published a list of the names of known homosexuals. How long would it take for the ACLU to decide the right to privacy took precedence over freedom of the press?

Oh, and the Sandusky Register really should start running photographs and names of women spotted entering abortion clinics. The public has a right to know, doesn't it?
I'm Voting for Virtue Soup for President

This is half-way between humor and multicultural absurdity:
Mitt Romney's been called many things as he runs for president, but chances are "Sticky Rice" isn't one of them.

That's how his name might be read on some Massachusetts ballots, according to state Secretary William Galvin.

Galvin says the federal Justice Department is pressuring Boston election officials to translate candidates' names into Chinese characters in precincts with prominent Chinese-speaking populations.

But there's more than a little lost in translation, according to Galvin.

Since there's no Chinese character for "Romney," translators have resorted to finding characters that most closely match the sound of each syllable in the name.

The problem is that there are many different characters that could be used to match the sound of each syllable, and many different meanings for each character.

So Mitt Romney could be read as "Sticky Rice" or "Uncooked Rice." Fred Thompson might be read as "Virtue Soup." And Barack Obama could be read as "Oh Bus Horse."

Galvin's own name could be read at least two different ways, as "High Prominent Noble Educated" or "Stick Mosquito."

But perhaps the most perplexing translation would be for Boston Mayor Thomas Menino's name, which could be read as "Sun Moon Rainbow Farmer" or "Imbecile," or "Barbarian Mud No Mind of His Own."

"To try to make rhymes or approximations in Chinese, you can have unintended negative meanings," Galvin said. "It leads to confusion. You can render it with a good meaning or a bad meaning."

To add to the confusion, Galvin said, the ballots have to be offered in two major Chinese dialects, Mandarin and Cantonese, leading to even more potential variations of candidates's names.

But advocates for minority voting rights say Galvin's objections are misdirected. If the translations are awkward, they say, the candidates should be free to offer variations, or look to the way Asian language newspapers already transliterate their names.

"We are looking to make sure Asian Americans are able to vote for their candidates of choice," Glenn Magpantay, staff attorney of the New York-based Asian American Defense Fund, told the Boston Globe. "This is difficult to do when voters with limited English proficiency cannot find those candidates."
If your English is so limited that you can't even recognize the candidate's name without having it weirdly transliterated, I really don't think you should be voting. If you don't read English, your knowledge of American politics is going to be substantially narrowed by only reading non-English news and opinion. It is rather like getting all of your news from television and radio because you don't know how to read. (And yes, this is an argument for requiring at least basic literacy in English to vote.)